Hitchcock on Universal DVD and Blu-ray
- Belmondo
- Joined: Thu Feb 08, 2007 9:19 am
- Location: Cape Cod
I do welcome them, but, the quality of the commentaries and bonus features will be the deciding factor on purchase vs. rental since I've already enjoyed the movies many times. I've never had to cut back on my DVD purchases because of money issues, but, I'm really starting to notice the high cost of living and the economic slowdown is beginning to hit home. My plan is to wait a week or two after the release date and let all of you tell me if the bonus material and transfers are:souvenir wrote:You complainers are all mad. Anamorphic versions of Vertigo and Psycho do not exist in R1 outside the Masterpiece box. If you're upset for having shelled out on that set now that more extra features are available then that's no reason to take it out on Universal. These releases are more than welcomed. Supplements are just that - extra features to enjoy (or not) alongside the film.
a) good enough to demand a purchase, or
b) rent them and use the money to buy a quarter of a tank of gas on your way to the video store.
- LightBulbFilm
- Joined: Wed Nov 16, 2005 5:11 pm
- Location: Florida
- Contact:
-
- Joined: Tue Nov 02, 2004 3:09 pm
- Location: here and there
- headacheboy
- Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 8:57 pm
Last December amazon sold the Masterpiece Collection for $56. I'm a Prime member and I snapped it up. Coincidentally enough I have only just now had the opportunity to watch these films having spent this past weekend watching Rear Window, Vertigo and Psycho. I was surprised to see these titles listed over on Beaver. I'm in agreement, the films looked great, the extras were worthwhile and I'm certain Universal is looking to bleed collectors dry. (Of course, I can rationally explain why I have 24 different copies of Dylan's Blonde On Blonde so I've no room to scorn Universal's actions.)
- denti alligator
- Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 9:36 pm
- Location: "born in heaven, raised in hell"
Let's see:headacheboy wrote: I have 24 different copies of Dylan's Blonde On Blonde so I've no room to scorn Universal's actions.)
1. Original mono LP
2. Original stereo LP
3. Sundazed mono vinyl reissue
4. 8-track
5. cassette
6. Original Columbia CD
7. Gold CD edition
8. Sony SACD hyrbid
Help me! 24 different copies?
- Jean-Luc Garbo
- Joined: Thu Dec 09, 2004 1:55 am
- Contact:
-
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 10:42 pm
- Location: London, England
Getting back on track, I can live without the isolated Psycho score, and a little grain. But for me the largest omission will bite, and bite hard. That is the US censor cut footage, aired a few times in Germany on their public TV.
Frame grabs of the infamous censored 18.36 seconds are featured in this article.
Frame grabs of the infamous censored 18.36 seconds are featured in this article.
-
- Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2007 8:29 pm
- Location: Los Angeles CA
- Contact:
Live with a little grain? Films are supposed to have grain. I couldn't live with it if it didn't have grain.Daliah Lavi wrote:Getting back on track, I can live without the isolated Psycho score, and a little grain. But for me the largest omission will bite, and bite hard. That is the US censor cut footage, aired a few times in Germany on their public TV.
-
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 10:42 pm
- Location: London, England
Yes, that was one of my points.Adam wrote:Live with a little grain? Films are supposed to have grain. I couldn't live with it if it didn't have grain.Daliah Lavi wrote:Getting back on track, I can live without the isolated Psycho score, and a little grain. But for me the largest omission will bite, and bite hard. That is the US censor cut footage, aired a few times in Germany on their public TV.
Some will moan about the (natural) grain and, to my mind extraneous extras. Just give me the film as the director intended, i.e. uncut!
-
- Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2008 3:31 am
- Location: Somerset, England
According to a 2006 post on the Hitchcock Wiki Forum (which nobody contradicted) the current R1 DVDs do include this previously censored footage:Daliah Lavi wrote:I can live without the isolated Psycho score, and a little grain. But for me the largest omission will bite, and bite hard. That is the US censor cut footage, aired a few times in Germany on their public TV.
JamesBW wrote:Yes, the Universal DVD are "uncut."
It seems the omission of those shots was peculiar to certain markets back in the early 60s (when "Psycho" was enjoying its first runs), or to TV showings. Biographer Patrick MacGilligan mentions some of them, for example the one where we see blood on Norman's hands. Since those days of yesteryear, we in the States, at least, have all seen and are very familiar with these cut scenes. Nothing new here.
I couldn't tell what the insert with the letter was. It looked sort of like they replaced the letter Mr. H shot (written in English) with a badly photographed insert of a letter shot by another crew (written in German? French? the image is not clear), presumably for foreign audiences.
-
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 10:42 pm
- Location: London, England
Sadly they're incorrect, anyone who currently owns the Universal region CE, can compare for themselves. It is still the censored US print.
The spied undressing is still missing the bra removal as highlighted in the frame grabs from the German TV broadcast. This is shown in the making of under Chapter 20 of the R1 CE.
As is the walk towards the sink to wash his bloodied hands. Again as shown in the German TV frame grabs.
The stabbing of the detective, now at the foot of the stairs, is still missing a further couple of stabs. This fades to black on the US dvd, while the German print carries on further.
Fascinating to see just what was originally cut. And as I mentioned before, I would expect Universal to pull out all the stops, and restore this classic to its true director's cut.
Hell, if it can happen to James Whale's Frankenstein...
The spied undressing is still missing the bra removal as highlighted in the frame grabs from the German TV broadcast. This is shown in the making of under Chapter 20 of the R1 CE.
As is the walk towards the sink to wash his bloodied hands. Again as shown in the German TV frame grabs.
The stabbing of the detective, now at the foot of the stairs, is still missing a further couple of stabs. This fades to black on the US dvd, while the German print carries on further.
Fascinating to see just what was originally cut. And as I mentioned before, I would expect Universal to pull out all the stops, and restore this classic to its true director's cut.
Hell, if it can happen to James Whale's Frankenstein...
Last edited by Daliah Lavi on Mon Aug 04, 2008 5:31 am, edited 2 times in total.
-
- Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2008 3:31 am
- Location: Somerset, England
Thanks for the clarification and confirmation. I checked the R1 CE myself, as you suggest. (For anyone else who wants to do so, the timings on the German site are slightly different due to PAL speed-up.)
The odd thing is I feel sure I've seen at least some of this censored footage at some point (maybe in the doc, as you say). I used to have a UK TV broadcast - which I watched more often than I've seen the DVD - and wonder now if it was in that. Can anyone who owns different DVD editions (maybe other regions?) or TV broadcasts check for this footage, please.
Is Dave Pattern (who runs the Hitchcock Wiki site) aware of this? I'm surprised I haven't come across this issue before, which is why - I admit - I was initially sceptical of your claim, especially after I found an uncontradicted denial!
EDIT: looking at the timings of the various DVD releases on the Hitchcock Wiki site, the Masterpiece Collection release is given as 28 seconds longer than that for the earlier CE edition. Has anyone checked the later transfer?
The odd thing is I feel sure I've seen at least some of this censored footage at some point (maybe in the doc, as you say). I used to have a UK TV broadcast - which I watched more often than I've seen the DVD - and wonder now if it was in that. Can anyone who owns different DVD editions (maybe other regions?) or TV broadcasts check for this footage, please.
Is Dave Pattern (who runs the Hitchcock Wiki site) aware of this? I'm surprised I haven't come across this issue before, which is why - I admit - I was initially sceptical of your claim, especially after I found an uncontradicted denial!
EDIT: looking at the timings of the various DVD releases on the Hitchcock Wiki site, the Masterpiece Collection release is given as 28 seconds longer than that for the earlier CE edition. Has anyone checked the later transfer?
-
- Joined: Sat Jul 05, 2008 8:37 am
- Location: UK
MANY thanks for the link to the Cut Psycho footage very interesting!
Ran to check my dvd/videos of the film and yes (SADLY!) the US collectors edition is missing all those shots, (its also missing the Cow shot LOL) like many i didnt double dip for the release collection so would love to know how that compares.
And would like to add that the memory of the previous poster is right as i also have a old VHS copy of the film from a UK tv showing and the footage is in that version, sadly my video quality is now terrible, no sound and picture rolls urgh!
Hope Universal takes the chance of this new release to restore the footage to this important film, or will they wait for their next Hitchcock rerelease!
Ran to check my dvd/videos of the film and yes (SADLY!) the US collectors edition is missing all those shots, (its also missing the Cow shot LOL) like many i didnt double dip for the release collection so would love to know how that compares.
And would like to add that the memory of the previous poster is right as i also have a old VHS copy of the film from a UK tv showing and the footage is in that version, sadly my video quality is now terrible, no sound and picture rolls urgh!
Hope Universal takes the chance of this new release to restore the footage to this important film, or will they wait for their next Hitchcock rerelease!
-
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 10:42 pm
- Location: London, England
[url=http://url]URL text[/url]
You're welcome. I'm actually surprised this isn't common knowledge.
I've sent out an alert to The Digital Bits, Tim Lucas of Video Watchdog, Rue Morgue the Canadian genre magazine and for what it's worth the editor of Fangoria.
Could someone alert Universal USA to the cuts and link to the cuts page. I really don't want to lose this chance of getting an uncut version restored..although it may already be too late.
Tim Lucas has very kindly written about my cause on his blog
For what it's worth, lets spread the word gentlemen!
I've sent out an alert to The Digital Bits, Tim Lucas of Video Watchdog, Rue Morgue the Canadian genre magazine and for what it's worth the editor of Fangoria.
Could someone alert Universal USA to the cuts and link to the cuts page. I really don't want to lose this chance of getting an uncut version restored..although it may already be too late.
Tim Lucas has very kindly written about my cause on his blog
For what it's worth, lets spread the word gentlemen!
-
- Joined: Thu Jun 22, 2006 9:47 am
-
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 10:42 pm
- Location: London, England
So that confirms the Masterpiece collection is still the censored edition. Thank you.
If my highlighting of the cuts doesn't make a difference at Universal, we'll more than likely have the same version on the forthcoming 2 disc set.
I've been reliably informed the first German VHS also featured this uncut version. And I'm hearing that the pre cert UK VHS was the same deal...
If my highlighting of the cuts doesn't make a difference at Universal, we'll more than likely have the same version on the forthcoming 2 disc set.
I've been reliably informed the first German VHS also featured this uncut version. And I'm hearing that the pre cert UK VHS was the same deal...
-
- Joined: Mon Nov 06, 2006 1:39 pm
- Location: UK
I can confirm that the uncut version was screened several times by the BBC in the 1980s.Jonathan S wrote:I used to have a UK TV broadcast - which I watched more often than I've seen the DVD - and wonder now if it was in that. Can anyone who owns different DVD editions (maybe other regions?) or TV broadcasts check for this footage, please?
-
- Joined: Tue Nov 02, 2004 2:27 pm
- Location: London, UK
Well, the pre-cert VHS can be picked up on Ebay for a bit over a fiver.Daliah Lavi wrote:I've been reliably informed the first German VHS also featured this uncut version. And I'm hearing that the pre cert UK VHS was the same deal...
-
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 10:42 pm
- Location: London, England
-
- Joined: Mon Nov 06, 2006 1:39 pm
- Location: UK
Yep. Here's the cover. Interesting to note that Gus Van Sant's PSYCHO remake uses the same angles as the censored version during the scene in which Norman washes his hands.Daliah Lavi wrote:I've a niggling feeling, there was a release prior to that, in a slip case perhaps?
-
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 10:42 pm
- Location: London, England
Thanks Brad, amazing how I could picture that 1981 release slip case after all these years. I note that release shares the same running time as the hard case 1985 edition currently on eBay...
Btw Brad, your assistance would be much appreciated over here. The historians are rebelling.
Further proof the censored footage was perhaps included in European prints
This rather shows up the 'Hitchcock specialists', allowing such important information to slip right under their noses.
Btw Brad, your assistance would be much appreciated over here. The historians are rebelling.
Further proof the censored footage was perhaps included in European prints
This rather shows up the 'Hitchcock specialists', allowing such important information to slip right under their noses.
-
- Joined: Mon Nov 06, 2006 1:39 pm
- Location: UK